#15 of 2012: The Off Season by Catherine Gilbert Murdock
Sad news: I didn’t quite find this sequel as enjoying as the previous book. I got engaged, yes, but that didn’t necessarily mean I was entertained. It was like I just wanted to get on with it and find out what all happened between DJ and Brian (his maybe boyfriend and Dale and Amber (the maybe-lesbian couples), to DJ’s dad’s hips and her mom’s fitness goals, to DJ’s brothers if they were ever making a cameo (they did - in fact, that made up half of the book and most of the story). DJ was as self-deprecating as ever, and chatty in her mind alone, and while I did appreciate the consistency of the character there, I wish Catherine Gilbert Murdock made her grow.Yay!-Still grounded in reality. Murdock knows when to stop milking the strengths in her story so that readers will come back for more.Boo!-Unfortunately, this Yay! has its downside for me: The urge to come back for more is not v. strong. I think I’ll pick up the next book just to find out how it’s all going to end.

#15 of 2012: The Off Season by Catherine Gilbert Murdock

Sad news: I didn’t quite find this sequel as enjoying as the previous book. I got engaged, yes, but that didn’t necessarily mean I was entertained. It was like I just wanted to get on with it and find out what all happened between DJ and Brian (his maybe boyfriend and Dale and Amber (the maybe-lesbian couples), to DJ’s dad’s hips and her mom’s fitness goals, to DJ’s brothers if they were ever making a cameo (they did - in fact, that made up half of the book and most of the story). DJ was as self-deprecating as ever, and chatty in her mind alone, and while I did appreciate the consistency of the character there, I wish Catherine Gilbert Murdock made her grow.

Yay!
-Still grounded in reality. Murdock knows when to stop milking the strengths in her story so that readers will come back for more.

Boo!
-Unfortunately, this Yay! has its downside for me: The urge to come back for more is not v. strong. I think I’ll pick up the next book just to find out how it’s all going to end.

about
all books
best reads per year
blog
review policy
view archive


Hi! I try to read 120 books a year, with lots of it young adult. Talk nerdy to me at onetwentybooks@gmail.com! More? Click this!

Ask anything




Books & Literature - Top Blogs Philippines

Read the Printed Word!

twitter.com/onetwentybooks


70 books
Anna Reads
Cate's Reading Good Books
Chachic's Book Nook
Chick Loves Lit
Citizen Judie
Cinderella in Rubber Shoes
Forever Young Adult
Presenting Leonore
Tarie's Asia in the Heart, World on the Mind
Tina's One More Page
YA Highway